" 7 Deadly Sins" of bad volunteering
Okay, so "7 Deadly Sins" might be a bit harsh, but these are some things we urge volunteers to consider...
1. "Don't go on a 'Hug an orphan' vacation"
Hugs are nice. We all love hugs. But what are you really achieving? Could you be hurting the very people you set out to help? Who are you doing this for, the children or yourself?
Negatively impacting the people you set out to help through promoting or perpetuating abuse of vulnerable people is a deeply rooted problem with the "have's" travelling to the "have-nots". Volunteers are attracted to work at orphanages as it's perceived as a direct way of helping, but transitory contact by those unqualified to work with children can have hugely damaging effects. There are a lot of good childcare projects, but if you are not a trained and qualified childcare professional, then maybe you are wrong for the job. Think about what you are qualified to do: perhaps there are important tasks that you can help with, such as plumbing or fundraising?
There is another, more insidious, problem with volunteering at orphanages. The "orphanage business" is booming and, like any business, the rules of supply and demand will apply – however, in this situation they can be perverse. Our experience has shown us that if you build an orphanage, orphans will become available. Opportunists may take advantage of the situation, exploiting vulnerable children to attract volunteers. Very often, government policy is in fact at odds with the international NGO's orphanage approach to childcare; many governments favour placing the children in homes with relatives or family friends rather than separating them from their community.
TEV does not promote working with orphanages, but if you must, be sure to limit the negative impacts you have on the children in its care.
2. "You people love empty buildings with your name on them"
This is something we have heard directed at NGO's by the local host community. The NGO comes in, builds a school, reports the success of the project to the donors and leaves. Unfortunately, the local community were not involved in the decision making process and were subsequently unable to afford to maintain the building or pay teacher salaries. This is not only wasteful, but avoidable. Be sensitive to the needs of the area. Make sure the project you are working for is addressing the needs of the local community, not set up in response to the needs of volunteers. Without community ownership and vested interests, project sustainability is drawn into question. Even the extent to which the volunteer is welcomed by the community could be compromised.
The concern with profit focused agencies is that the nature of their business is to satisfy volunteers needs before those of the host community . When your primary focus is profit, then the host community is always secondary at best.
3. "Be an asset, not a necessity"
You are not going to be staying very long: if the project becomes reliant on your presence and you leave, how have you helped? You shouldn't replace a teacher, a builder or any other capable member of the community. Your placement could be taking away from an opportunity to create local employment. If your presence in the project is necessary, then what happens when you leave? The sustainability of a project is often the measure of its success. But isn't doing something better than nothing? – Yes but doesn't this sound like an excuse? Why stop there? You can do so much more! If you want to do it right, think more about it. Think about the bigger picture; the knock-on effect of your actions can be negative as well as positive.
4. "White in Shining Armour"
The "hero" syndrome of the white-guys-in-khaki.
Some view volunteering as just another form of colonialism. The white man coming to save the poor man from their poverty. "Save the world", "Make a Big Difference", "Rescue the Victims" - the marketing phrases that establish a giver and receiver create an imbalanced relationship (and sound uncannily like the missionaries of the 19th century...). Adopting the role of learner is a far better experience for you and the host community. Let's not look at it as "giving"; volunteering is about immersing yourself in the lives of other people and their local culture. Be honest with yourself, you are there for a new experience; you are travelling the world in the spirit of adventure, eager for a cultural exchange.
Exchange is about giving and receiving in return. Solidarity is built as you gain an understanding of the lives of other people by taking the time to learn about their situation. Look at it from the other point of view: a lot of the people you will meet do not get the chance to travel abroad, and so you bring the chance to experience your culture to the local people: a cultural exchange. Access to other cultures is now facilitated and both sides gain new perspectives on life.
And if you happen to be a young independent woman ,you are demonstrating and promoting woman's rights and progress. Women in the locality see you travelling as equals to men. Don't underestimate the positive effect this can have.
By adopting the role of learner you give your host community they respect they deserve.
5. "Profiteering from Poverty"
While not all agencies are inherently bad, if the goal is to maximize profits by perpetuating images of poverty and misery, then there is something fundamentally wrong with the agency's model. Many of these agencies use images of poverty to encourage others to fork out thousands of Euros to "save the world" and subsequently profit from a business that is damaging to many involved. And what's in it for these agencies in the long run? Well, think about it – if you make money from someone's poverty, it's not in your interest to stamp it out for ever. If it is only profits that drive the agency, then they are more responsible to shareholders than the poor.
6. "Make a huge difference"… in two weeks?
It takes time for a volunteer to be useful. Even the most capable and well educated volunteer will have a period of adjustment to go through. Be aware of the resources required to settle you in. It will take time to feel your way around a project before you can find your place and the best way you can contribute. Short term volunteering uses valuable resources of a charity. The longer the time you immerse yourself in the community, the higher the chance that you will be of benefit.
We often get asked "How long should I volunteer for?", which is kind of like "how long is a piece of string?". While this all depends on the project, the placement, your skills etc., let's say, at the very minimum, one month. Anything less and you are just finding your feet without time to get anything done. In general, we recommend three months: the first to settle in, the second to get acquainted with what's to be done and the third to actually get your teeth stuck in. And remember, you are working a normal job and so will have time off. Be sure to give yourself enough time to experience what your country has to offer during that time and to make friends with the local community. These things take time and are as valuable as the work you will be doing.
7. Do your homework
There is an arrogance about sailing off into the sunset to "be of help" when you know next to nothing about the culture, politics, history and economics of the country you are about to visit. Do your research. Learn about the factors that have contributed to the development of the country you will be visiting. Show those you will be working with the respect of knowing at least a few words of their language. You'll feel more confident, more prepared and you will add to your ability to make a positive impact on those you are setting out to help
e-learning: Guide to Ethical Volunteering
The following e-learning tool aims to highlight some of the ethical considerations to be taken into account when preparing for, carrying out, and returning from an overseas volunteering placement. The general rules for safe travel apply and are not dealt with in this package; our aim is to highlight some basic issues you may not have considered and to guide you in making the right decisions. For the most part, this document is not about you, the volunteer, but about the organisation you are applying to and the communities that will host you. We do not provide absolutes; the aim is provoke thought and critical thinking. At the end of the day, it’s up to you to make a considered decision when it comes to volunteering. We just aim to give you the tools to do that.
This document is not difficult, but requires a bit of reading and there are also a few short films to watch, so its going to take an hour or two.... go make a cup of tea and get comfortable!
Click here: Guide to Ethical Volunteering
Kariba South Primary School – a happy little place where the lessons are more than just academic.
I’ve talked about the misuse of images before and I think this is an interesting one – we could have framed this photo (children in a wheelbarrow) differently to portray an image of poverty. In fact, we could have taken all manner of photos of the school to convey the type of message we wanted, whether that was one of hope or desperation....read more
For many more blogs on volunteering, development and our preconceptions of the "developing world", click here
The Problem of Poaching (Blog): http://theproblemofpoaching.wordpress.com
Comhlamh: Guides to ethical volunteering
Good Intentions Are Not Enough: Thought provoking debates on charity and giving
Dead Aid: Why aid is not working and how there is another way for Africa, Dambisa Moyo
White Mans Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good, William Easterly
The Bottom Billion: Why the Poorest Countries are Failing and What Can Be Done About, Paul Collier
The Mobile phone: A symbol of development across Africa
Sub-Saharan Africa is open for business. Foreign direct investment across the continent is increasing while GDP rates in many countries are significantly higher than in Europe and the Middle East. “Africa is good for business and business is good for Africa” and nothing represents the economic development and current landscape than the mobile phone... read more
Poverty Porn: The misuse of images from the developing world
I grew up in a semi-rural area in Ireland, around 3km from the town of Bray. My parents worked fulltime and a neighbour looked after me as a child. The regional buses then, as now, were painfully unreliable and so many of my afternoons were taken up by walking to the supermarket in town and back. We were not the only ones making the trip by foot to the shops, there were others from my area that we would pass on the road. One lady in particular, Nancy, passed us everyday day... read more
Volunteering abroad – avoiding the pitfalls and negative consequences
I have been reading many articles and forums recently that highlight the possible negative impacts of volunteering (or that are outright anti-volunteering). Much has been said in these international forums condemning voluntourism as new age colonialism and exploitation and, in many cases, what is being said is true, in one way or another. Personally, I have seen both positive and negative sides to volunteering and think that somewhere in between starry-eyed naivety and steadfast cynicism.... read more